Monday, February 8, 2016

Mario Bros.

Name: Mario Bros.
Year: 1986
Publisher: Nintendo
Developer: Nintendo
Genre: Arcade, Platformer (Single Screen)
Hours Played: Countless
Beaten: N/A
High Score: 77,710
After Donkey Kong (1981) but before Super Mario Bros. (1985) came the arcade game Mario Bros.  Although it was a one-screen platformer, in the vein of it's predecessor, it would introduce many of the elements that would become Mario staples, including sewer pipes, malevolent turtles, momentum when you run, falling from any height, and of course Mario's green-clad brother Luigi.

Every level has the same layout, and features Mario (and in two-player co-op mode, Luigi) running around platforms, attempting to hit enemies from beneath to stun them and then touch them head-on to knock them out of commission.  Like many older arcade games, the challenge comes from keeping track of everything on screen at once; stunned enemies get up and move faster if ignored for too long, fireballs appear unexpectedly at the edge of the screen, and sentient icicles can freeze platform sections.  For true chaos, add in a second player; bumping into them can send both of you ricocheting into enemies (a mechanic later revisited in the New Super Mario Bros. games).

Unlike so many of the games in it's vault, Nintendo has figured out exactly where this game belongs: as a free mini-game. You can play a slightly updated version as a battle game in Super Mario Bros. 3, play it in full from the SMB3 title screen in Super Mario Bros. All-Stars, and it's included in numerous Game Boy Advance Titles (Super Mario Advance 1-4, Mario & Luigi).  Interestingly, all of these use the NES version of the game, as opposed to the technically superior arcade version, suggesting that Nintendo considers this the "real" version of the game (or at least the easiest to port).

Mario Bros., along with Balloon Fight, was one of the first competitive co-op games, and still holds up when played with two players.  That being said, it's short length made it difficult to justify a $50 price tag even back in 1986, and with the release of Super Mario Bros. 3 in 1990, this cartridge became all but obsolete.

Graphics & Animation: 3 (Average)
The graphics here are pretty good;  Mario, the green sewer pipes, and the Koopas (known back then as "Shellcreepers") are instantly recognizable.  For such  a short game, though, I wish they could have included the extra animations from the arcade game (Mario burning when he touches a fireball, turles stepping outside their shells and flipping them over, etc).

Music & Sounds: 1 (Bad)
No in-game music (except little ditties when the game starts), and the sound effects, while effective, are sparse.  Not much to say because there's not much here.

Controls & Level Design: 4 (Good)
The controls in Super Mario Bros. are top-notch, and it's easy to see why: Nintendo was perfecting them all the way back with this game.  Although there's no "run" button, momentum (jumping higher when running, sliding when you turn quickly) still plays a huge part in this game, forcing you to be aware of enemies' positions at all times lest you leap headfirst into one...

Story & Presentation: 1 (Bad)
Not much to say here.  The title screen looks pretty good (better then most of the black box arcade games, actually), and there's a nice little melting effect when the icicles freeze the platforms... and that's about it.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 1 (Bad)
Multiplayer is the only reason to keep coming back to this game, but even then, you're going to get tired of Mario Bros. pretty quickly.

Total: 9 (Average)

Friday, February 5, 2016

Q*Bert

Name: Q*Bert
Year: 1989
Publisher: Ultra Software
Developer: Gottlieb
Genre: Arcade, Isometric Platformer
Hours Played: Countless
Beaten: N/A
When arcade games began stealing quarters away from pinball machines in the seventies, it was only natural that pinball companies would start producing their own video games.  One such company, Gottlieb, produced dozens of popular pinball machines, but only ever managed one successful video game.  But oh, what a one-hit wonder it was.

The concept for Q*Bert began when doodles by artist Jeff Lee, involving Kustom Kulture-inspired characters moving around an M. C. Escher-inspired landscape, were discovered by programmer Warren Davis, who wanted to practice implementing gravity and physics in a video game.  The resulting prototype was discovered by executives at Gottlieb, and the results became the world's first isometric perspective video game.

Like most one-screen arcade games, the premise of Q*Bert is simple.  You hop around a pyramid built of cubes while avoiding enemies.  Every spot you land on turns that cube a different color, and when you've landed on every cube, you progress to the next level.  Teleportation disks on the sides of the pyramid serve the same purpose as the warp tunnels in Pac-Man, allowing for quick escapes from enemies.  Besides bouncing eggs and snakes, Q*Bert must also avoid enemies who walk on the "wrong" sides of the cubes (defying gravity), and catch green creatures who will undo the tiles you've turned.

Nowadays, Q*Bert is mostly known for his appearances in movies such as Wreck-It Ralph and Pixels, and this is largely because his rights are currently owned by Sony, but in his heyday the popularity of Q*Bert rivaled that of Pac-Man.  Their were toys, board games, and even a cartoon show.  While the game isn't fondly remembered as Donkey Kong or DK JR, the gameplay has held up better, still presenting an enjoyable romp today.  There's definitely better games on the NES, and the simple gameplay hardly justifies a $50 price tag, but if you've never experienced Q*Bert, it's definitely worth a moment of your time.

Graphics & Animation: 2 (Average)
While it's hardly the worst looking port of Q*Bert, the graphics of Q*Bert aren't anything to write home about.  Still, everything from the arcade is at least recognizable...

Music & Sounds: 0 (Awful)
If you're going to port a game with no music, you can at least make sure you've got the sound effects right! Maybe Q*Bert's signature "cussing" sound effect was just too hard to mimic, I dunno; but seeing as how there's plenty of NES games with digitized speech, and we're only talking about one (famous) sound effect, it seems a little lousy of them to leave it out.

Controls & Level Design: 3 (Good)
The level design in Q*Bert is simple, but classic, and as more levels progress, changing the color of the tiles becomes more complicated.  The control scheme can take a little getting used to, but they added a comprehensive set-up screen for changing the controls to your liking.

Story & Presentation: 3 (Good)
The presentation here is actually fairly impressive!  Most notable is the game's controller setup screen, which features an NES controller and a Q*Bert player to guide you through the process of configuring your controls.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 1 (Bad)
The latter levels giving you new goals gives the game a little longevity, but the truth is, Q*Bert is one of those games where you've seen everything the game has to offer after five minutes.

Total: 9 (Average)

Wednesday, February 3, 2016

Battle Chess

Name: Battle Chess
Year: 1990
Publisher: Data East
Developer: Beam Software
Genre: Board Game
Hours Played:
Beaten: No, I suck at chess
Battle Chess was a novelty game for computers and consoles in the late eighties/early nineties.  The concept is simple: it's just standard chess, but when you move, the pieces get up and walk around, and when you capture another piece, you get to watch the two characters fight each other.  The game is loaded with over 100 animations, as every possible paring of pieces has it's own unique battle animations, and the charm of the game comes from the different character's personalities: knights creak and lumber around the board, rooks transform into rock monsters, etc.

Although it's not widley remembered now, Battle Chess was very popular (espicially for PC) and spawned a number of sequels and spinoffs; however, unlike contemperary cult classics like Archon, there doesn't seem to be any indication of a Battle Chess remake or revival or Kickstarter (EDIT: turns out I was wrong).  That's because unfortunately, like all novelties, the novelty of Battle Chess eventually wears off.  The appeal of the game is to show off your hardware to your friends, and see how many different kill animations you can discover; once you've done that, you're left with a pretty standard chess simulation.  If you just want to play chess on your NES, you're better off sticking with Chess Master: it has a teaching mode for beginners and better AI for experts.  But if you want your friends to think you're smart while watching medieval characters kill each other, there's always Battle Chess.

Graphics & Animation: 4 (Excellent)
The animation is the showcase here, and the NES does a pretty good job of mimicking it's PC brethren.  There's over a hundred different battle animations (one for every possible combination of attacker/defender), and each piece has it's own distinct personality.

Music & Sounds: 2 (Average)
This is one case where I don't mind the lack of music during the main game, as true chess players would probably find it a little distracting.  The grunts and groans of the combatants are a nice touch, though.

Controls & Level Design: 1 (Bad)
The game controls just fine (although I wish it had a cancel button), and I can't really fault chess for a lack of level design.  My main complain here is the lack of options; compared to Chess Master, this is a pretty bare-bones representation.

Story & Presentation: 4 (Excellent)
This cartridge may have more cutscenes then any other single NES game, thanks to all the unique battles between the pieces.  The game has a style all of it's own - it's actually pretty violent for an NES game.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 1 (Bad)
Trying to find every combination of pieces will keep you entertained for a little while... but after that, you'd better really like chess.

Total: 12 (Average)

Monday, February 1, 2016

Millipede

Name: Millipede
Year: 1988
Publisher: HAL Laboratory
Developer: Atari
Genre: Arcade
Hours Played: 2
Beaten: N/A
Centipede was a wildly successful arcade game released in 1980.  A single-screen shooter in the vain of Space Invaders or Galaga, Centipede broke new ground (no pun intended) by having the game take place in a garden instead of space, and filling the screen with harmless, stationary objects (mushrooms) that obstruct your shots at the enemy (spiders, fleas, and the titular centipede).  The object is to destroy the centipede as he travels down the screen, and shooting him causes him to split into smaller centipedes.

The game was successful enough to see a sequel, Millipede, in 1982.  Besides introducing a couple new elements (DDT bombs, new enemy behaviors), the game was mostly the same, and never enjoyed the popularity of it's predecessor.  While Centipede was ported to all the consoles and computer systems of it's day, Millipede only managed a handful of ports.

And yet, it was Millipede and not Centipede that Atari chose to port to the NES in 1988.  Prehaps they figured that sinse their wasn't that much difference between the games, it only made since to pick the "superior" version.  Whatever the reason, the NES port of Milipede is a little... lacking.

The biggest problem here is the playing field.  Millipede for NES only uses about two thirds of the screen, leaving the rest as a green border.  It's truly baffling; the NES is capable of fairly accurate graphics for Pac-Man, Galaga, and Joust, but apparently the bugs and mushrooms of Millipede were just too much for it?  The game feels like a port of a computer version, rather then a direct arcade port.

And... that's it.  Honestly, I've run out of things to say about this game.  It's an awful-looking port of a moderately playable arcade game, and I can think of literally hundreds of NES games I would buy over this one.

Graphics & Animation: 0 (Awful)
Millipede was never exactly the most graphically impressive game, but it was at least colorful and appealing; this is just abysmal.  I usually try not to compare NES game to games for other systems. but com'on - Centipede for the Atari 7800 looked better then this, and this is a sequel game on a more powerful console!

Music & Sounds: 1 (Bad)
The arcade sound effects are pretty accurately recreated here.  Unfortunately, the game has no music, not even when you start or end a level.

Controls & Level Design: 3 (Average)
The controls are a little slippery, and the levels just repeat endlessly, but that's all in keeping with it's arcade heritage, so I can't fault it too much there.  Unlike the original Centipede, Millipede adds a grayed out effect to the bottom of the screen to make it clearer where your ship's boundaries are - a useful (if not as visually appealing) touch.

Story & Presentation: 0 (Awful)
HAL game this game a scaled down presentation, similar to the title screens of Donkey Kong and Balloon Fight on the NES - and this was three years later. I hate to keep repeating this, but... Centipede on the Atari 7800 looked better then this!!

Length & Replayabilitiy: 0 (Awful)
I complain about arcade games like Joust and Pac-Man for being just one level that repeats over and over and over, but at least those were good quality ports.  This is abysmal.

Total: 4 (Bad)

Friday, January 29, 2016

Xevious

Name: Xevious: The Avenger
Year: 1988
Publisher: Bandi
Developer: Namco
Genre: Shoot'em Up
Hours Played: Countless
Beaten: N/A
(Note: the official NES title of this game is "Xevious: The Avenger", but it's just a port of the original Xevious.  This kind of embellishment was a common practice for NES ports of arcade games.  It's especially odd in this case, since "Xevious" is the name of the planet, not the main character.)

Xevious is a vertical scrolling game originally released in 1982.  While it might not seem impressive at first glance, it's hard to explain just how influential it was at the time.  Although it wasn't the first vertical shooter, it was the first one to become well known, and it holds up surprisingly well.

The basic concept of Xevious is pretty easy to understand. You fly over a lush alien planet covered in forests, landing strips, and water, and try to destroy the enemy's vehicles and bases without getting destroyed yourself.  You start with the only two weapons in the game, a standard gun, and a bomb.  The gun is for airborn targets and the bomb works on land targets.  Both kind can fire back at you, and many airborne craft with attempt to ram you, as well.  Every so many levels there is a giant mothership (considered one of gaming's first bosses), which fires a barrage of bullets but can be destroyed with a single well-placed bomb.

While it all sounds simple enough, Xevious is a surprisingly difficult - and complex - game.  While most shooters of this type (Legendary Wings, 1942, etc) can be mastered with enough practice and memorization, Xevious has just enough elements of randomness to ensure that the enemy placement is never exactly the same on any two playthrus.  The result is, unlike most NES action games such as Mega Man, you'll never be able to get by simply learning the enemy patterns and reacting accordingly.  What's worse is that Xevious isn't scared to play dirty.  While enemy patterns seem fairly standard in the first few levels, as you progress, the game will throw at you everything from screen-sized multi-blasts, to heat-seeking bullets that chase you around, to enemies that fly up from the bottom of the screen (a serious violation of vertical scrolling conventions!).

Like most arcade games of it's ilk, Xevious continues indefinitely, but instead of simply repeating the same levels (a la Pac-Man), the game remixes and multiplies the enemy placement.  You know how after you beat Super Mario Bros, you get to play the game again, only all the Goombas are replaced with Buzy Beetles?  Imagine that, only instead of a congratulations screen, the game just cycles back to world 4, and for every Goomba there's now three Buzy Beetles and a Latuika.  Once you've progressed far enough, the game becomes the world's first bullet hell - I tried playing with save states, and literally reached a point I couldn't get past even while cheating.  That's my definition of a tough game.

All in all, Xevious is a well-crafted game that was ahead of it's time.  Every time you play it, it throws something new at you.  While it's considered a seminal shooter in Japan, it's never quite gained the same notoriety in America, and that's a shame; as far as endless shooters go, it doesn't get any better then this.

Graphics & Animation: 3 (Good)
Xevious does a whole lot with very little.  Using only a handful of colors and designs, the game is able to produce some pretty intricate landscapes for you to fly over - a refreshing change of pace from the endless starfields of most shmups.

Music & Sounds: 1 (Bad)
The good? The main theme does a nice job of evoking suspense.  The bad?  There's only two songs i the entire game - the main theme, and the tune that plays when you start a new life.  The music's iconic, but it gets old fast.

Controls & Level Design: 3 (Good)
The controls are very tight in this game, and the Solvalou (your ship) always goes where you want it to.  The dual-layered level design (air and ground targets, requiring two different weapons) still feels clever even thirty years later.

Story & Presentation: 1 (Bad)
There's a cool little effect in this game where, instead of announcing when you've made it to a new level, you instead fly over a large expanse of forest.  It's a cool little way of subtly letting the player know you're in new territory.  Other then that, there's not a lot of presentation to be had here.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 4 (Excellent)
This is one of the first video games I ever owned, meaning I've been playing it for about as long as I can remember, and in writing this review, I still came across new tricks and enemy types I'd never seen before.

Total: 12 (Average)

Wednesday, January 27, 2016

Mega Man 4

Name: Mega Man 4
Year: 1991
Publisher: Capcom
Developer: Capcom
Genre: Platformer
Hours Played: Countless
Beaten: Yes, without cheats
Mega Man 4 is often regarded as one of the "bad" Mega Man games - generally placing just after 6 and 1 in terms of people's general dislike for it.  Yet it doesn't have the unforgiving difficulty of the first game, or the poor level design of the sixth game, or even the odd control quirks of the third.  So why the poor reputation?

The answer is because, for better or worse, Mega Man 4 marks the point that the series became paint by numbers.  After the careful fine tuning of 2 and the unique storytelling chops of 3, the rest of the series from here on out would follow a careful formula: an opening cut scene introduces a new villain, Mega Man beats all 8 robot masters, tackles the new villain's castle and beats him, Dr. Wiley is revealed to be behind it, Mega Man tackles an all new Skull Castle and beats Dr. Wily. Again. Rinse and repeat.

You may be tempted to give Mega Man 4 a pass for this - after all, it's the first game to use this formula, right? (Assuming you don't count Dr. Wily's "surprise" betrayal in 3) But even here, it feels like the developers were more interested in trying to remake Mega Man 2 then they were in innovating.  Once again we have a water-theme villain (which until this point was only seen in MM2), a villain who shoots fire (1 and 2), an earth-theme villain (okay to be fair I think they all have one of those)... heck, with Bright Man they literally reused Flash Man's weapon and didn't even bother renaming it.  The last stage of the game also seems extremely familiar to those who've beaten Mega Man 2, right down to entering a dark room for the final boss, and having the lights come on in a lab when the fight's over.

The most controversial addition, however, is the Mega Buster, Mega Man's new default weapon. By holding the fire button for a few seconds, Mega Man can release a larger, more powerful shot.  This addition appeared in all the subsequent Mega Man games, and even other series, such as Mega Man X. Many fans feel this made the game "too easy" or took the emphasis off acquiring the bosses' weapons.  Is this true?  Well, yes and no.  Your standard weapon IS more powerful, not because of the charge shot (which only does x3 the damage of a normal bullet) but because the game no longer restricts you to only shooting three shots at a time.  Why even bother with the charge shot when you can pump an endless barrage of bullets into your enemy?  As for using the boss weapons, the issue is that Capcom greatly reduced the amount of damage that Robot Masters take from the the weapon their "weak" to, meaning their's less point in figuring out the correct weapon to use.  The result of all this is the easiest levels but hardest robot masters (and hardest boss rush) in the series up to this point.

All that being said, I would by no means call Mega Man 4 a bad game.  The music, while not as memorable as 2 or 3, is still leaps and bounds over most music on the NES, and the graphics are actually better then ever.  Mega Man 4 boasts the best opening cutscene (the only time we see Mega Man's origin recounted), the best "weapon get" screen, and the most colorful minibosses of the entire series.  There's even a couple moments of innovation: hearkening back  to the original Mega Man, there's two "adapter" items (one is a grappling hook, the other is Item 1 from MM2), and they're hidden in the robot master stages; finding them actually takes a little creative thinking, which I really enjoyed.

Graphics & Animation: 4 (Excellent)
Capcom was clearly trying to outdo themselves in the graphics department, and they succeeded: the over-sized cartoony enemies from three are even bigger and cartoonier here, there's more giant mini-bosses then ever, and the cutscenes (including the "get weapon" scenes) are the best in the series.  You'd be hard pressed to find a better looking game on the NES.

Music & Sounds: 3 (Good)
There's not as many "get stuck in your head and stay there forever" songs in this game as their are in the previous entries, but there's still some good ones (even years later, I can hum you Skull Man's music), and once again the sheer amount of different tunes in a single NES cartridge is impressive all on it's own.

Controls & Level Design: 3 (Good)
The controls here are tight, and for the first time ever, Mega Man doesn't fall off ladders if you pause and unpause the game.  In older games, Mega Man couldn't have more then three bullets on the screen at once, due to technical limitations of the NES; here, they resolved that problem, but didn't tweak the difficulty to account for it, meaning you can spam the fire button in a way not possible before.  The levels are a little lackluster as well, relying too heavily on minibosses then before - Ring Man's level stands out as an especially egregious example, with four minibosses and only a handful of obstacles otherwise.

Story & Presentation: 4 (Excellent)
Regardless of what everyone else at Capcom were doing, the art department was clearly under the impression they were working on the greatest Mega Man game ever, because everything in the presentation and cutscenes shines here.  While the opening cutscenes in the next two games would focus on setting up plot and red herring villians, the intro here is all about Mega Man himself, and gives us the more characterization about him then the other five games combined.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 3 (Good)
Technically the longest Mega Man game to date, but definitely not as replayable as some of the others.  The hidden items do add a little replayability to the game, though.

Total: 17 (Good)

Monday, January 25, 2016

Yoshi's Cookie

Name: Yoshi's Cookie
Year: 1993
Publisher: Nintendo
Developer: Bullet-Proof Software
Genre: Abstract Puzzler
Hours Played: 2
Beaten: No
When Tetris first came to the States from Russia in 1984, there were a lot of legal battles over who owned the rights (in Russia, according to laws at the time, the game was owned by the government and not the creator).  After many lawsuits, Nintendo ended up with the rights to the game, but only for a limited period of time.  They used those rights to push the Nintendo and especially the Game Boy to success (as Tetris co-creator Henk Rogers stated, "Tetris made Game Boy and Game Boy made Tetris").  The downside of all this was that Nintendo knew they couldn't keep the rights forever, and so the search was on to come up with a replacement.  Hence, during the NES's lifespan, Nintendo came out with a number of abstract puzzlers, including Yoshi, Dr. Mario, and Wario's Woods.  The game we'll be looking at today is Yoshi's Cookie.

Yoshi's Cookie is neither the best nor the worst of these games released by Nintendo; what it is is the most reflex based and least contemplative of the series.  At first glance, it looks like a predecessor to Candy Crush - everything from the arranging pieces game play to the confectionery theme feels immediately familiar.  But spend a couple of rounds with the game, and the huge differences quickly become clear. The relaxed gameplay in games like Bejeweled and Candy Crush is nowhere to be found; the emphasis in Yoshi's Cookie is strictly on making matches as quickly as possible before you get overwhelmed and the screen fills up, Tetris style.

The gameplay is simple: you have cookies in a rectangle-shaped grid, and more cookies fly in from the top and the right.  Arrange a row or column so that all the cookies match, and it clears that line.  Clear all the cookies, and you progress to the next stage.  The basic problem here is that the extra cookies come flying in pretty quickly, so it's near impossible to formulate any kind of long-term strategy; your only bet is to clear the screen as quickly as possible.  From what I've been able to determine (from my own gameplay and making family and friends try it), if you can't clear a screen in less then 30 seconds from when you start, the statistical chances of you making a comeback and beating it are very low.  It stops you from ever getting into the classic puzzle-game "trance"; you're too busy staying constantly on your toes.

As an experiment, I had my wife, who's obsessed with beating Candy Crush without purchases, try the game.  To my surprise, I (who hates Candy Crush) was much better at is then her; her abstract puzzle-solving strategies weren't nearly as useful as my gamer reflexes.  The end result is that the game doesn't satisfy either audience; she'd rather be playing a game at a casual, relaxed pace, and I'd rather be shooting bugs and stomping mushrooms.

Graphics & Animation: 2 (Average)
The graphics here aren't anything to write home about, but they are a lot of fun.  Everything here is easily identifiable, especially the cookies, and Yoshi looks pretty good rendered on an 8-bit system.

Music & Sounds: 1 (Bad)
The music here is pretty forgettable.  Not to compare games, but the Super Nintendo version has an opening theme that manages to sound like a Mario game without copying music from other games; why couldn't the NES version have anything that memorable?

Controls & Level Design: 1 (Bad)
The controls in this game are frustrating.  Unlike some puzzle games which purposely limit how you can move pieces (Yoshi, Tetris Attack/Puzzle League), in Yoshi's Cookie you're free to move any piece to any spot you like; so why make the controls so awkward?  Instead of simply picking and moving a piece, you grip a piece and then use the D-pad to slide that row or column around, sort of like a 15 puzzle game.  The titular Yoshi's Cookie (a cookie shaped like Yoshi's Head) is suppose to serve as a wild card, but it's extremely difficult to get it where you want it without accidentally making a match on the way.

Story & Presentation: 4 (Excellent)
The game is called "Yoshi's Cookie", and they drive that theme home wherever they can.  Mario wears a chef's outfit to oversee the playing field, and little Pac-Man-esc cutscenes play out every ten levels where Mario opens boxes of cookies and tries to hide them from Yoshi.  It's silly, but they still went the extra mile to include it,

Length & Replayability: 1 (Bad)
Kudos to the game for having a two-player mode, but also including a puzzle mode where you clear pre-designed boards (like the Super Nintendo version of Yoshi's Cookie) would have went a long way towards giving this game more replayability.

Total: 9 (Average)

Friday, January 22, 2016

Sesame Street: Countdown

Name: Sesame Street: Countdown
Year: 1992
Publisher: Hi-Tech Expressions
Developer: Riedel Software Productions
Genre: Educational
Hours Played: 2
Beaten: Yes
Sesame Street: Countdown was the last Sesame Street game released for the Nintendo Entertainment System.  Like the previous game (and unlike the first two), the game was developed specifically for the NES, and includes digitized speech.

The first thing you'll notice about Sesame Street: Countdown is that there's two modes, Hop and Run.  My feelings about the game vary greatly depending on which mode you pick.  If you pick Run, the game becomes an adequate (if enemy-less) platformer, not unlike Mickey's Safari in Letterland. Each level starts with a wheel of chance, which determines the number you'll be searching for in that level.  You then walk around as the Count, occasionally jumping or climbing on obstacles, looking for the number, groupings of objects that equal the number (e.g. a cluster of four ghosts if your number is 4), and lightning bolts.  Grabbing these things will gain you a point, and grabbing a wrong number or grouping will cost you a life point.  You begin the game with nine life points and only a three point minimum to finish the level, but with each subsequent level you need one more point and have one less hit point.  The game's hit detection is slightly off, but I actually think this was on purpose; you can brush a wrong number without being punished for it.

Where the game falls apart is when you pick Hop.  The idea here is to make the game playable, even for very small children.  It's the same game, with the same levels and the same game of chance at the beginning, but all of the platforming is removed.  Instead, the numbers and item groups are spaced out an even distance from one another, and instead of moving with the D-pad, you use either A or B to hop.  A hops you to the next number or grouping, while B makes you hop straight up, collecting it (or taking a hit).  All of the Sesame Street NES games share this problem to a certain extent, but Countdown by far has it the worst: by trying to simplify the controls, they actually make them more confusing.  While using a D pad feels very intuitive, trying to figure out which button hops you in the right direction does not.  I have trouble picturing a four year old, or an elderly parental figure trying to play with their child, being able to figure this out, and anybody in-between those two ages should be playing with the normal controls anyways.

In the end, I'm torn.  The educational value is certainly there; The Count teaches you how to count at the end of each level, and collecting groupings of objects (instead of just the number) will help your kids learn how to apply counting instead of just memorizing it.  The game was clearly built around Run mode, and as a "baby's first platformer", it works.  Hop mode, however, is a mess, and it's also the default mode (you have to move the cursor to pick "Run"), meaning it's the first, and probably only, mode most people will play.

Graphics & Animation: 2 (Average)
The graphics here are fine.  The Count is instantly recognizable, which of course is the most important thing, The first level takes place on Sesame Street, and the remaining six levels take place in locales ranging from prehistoric times to the moon, and finishing with the Count's castle.  Everything is recognizable, but not much stands out.

Music & Sounds: 4 (Excellent)
The Count talks!  The digitized voice here is very good, and the Count's counting sounds very natural, which is harder to pull off with digitized speech then you'd think (I'm looking at you, Mickey).  The music is fine as well, although I wish they'd included the classic theme song.

Controls & Level Design: 1 (Bad)
Honestly, I wish I could score the two modes as separate games.  Run mode controls pretty well, and being able to brush against an object without activating it, while annoying in most games, is actually a pretty nice touch here, as it means kids can accidentally bump into a wrong answer without getting penalized.  Hop mode, on the other hand, is inexcusably bad.

Story & Presentation: 2 (Average)
Like everything else with this game, I'm really torn on the presentation.  On the one hand, if you collect a lightning bolt, and you're already maxed out, the lightning bolt will fly up towards your status bar, ricochet off the lightning bolt tally box, and then fly exasperatedly away.  That's a really creative touch!  On the other hand, after beating a bonus challenge in the sky, the Count unceremoniously levitates  down the screen to the ground, making the game feel amateurish.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 1 (Bad)
Once again, I'm torn.  The random nature of which number you're looking for does give the game a little replayability, but by the time you finish the game's seven levels, you'll feel like you've seen everything the game has to offer.  If they had just left out Hop mode...

Total: 10 (Average)

Wednesday, January 20, 2016

Sesame Street: Big Bird's Hide & Speak

Name: Sesame Street: Big Bird's Hide & Speak
Year: 1990
Publisher: Hi-Tech Expressions
Developer: Riedel Software Productions
Genre: Educational
Hours Played: One
Beaten: Yes
Sesame Street: Big Bird's Hide & Speak is the third Sesame Street game released for the Nintendo Entertainment System; it's also the first one to be created specifically for the console, and the first NES game of any kind to feature digitized speech (i.e. the game talks).

When you start up the game, you're greeted by several walls of text (with copyright statements, credits, etc), and then an impressively large graphic of Big Bird skates onto the screen and gives you a choice of six different mini-games.  Oddly, there's no title screen with the game's name (unless you count it being crammed in among the walls of text), and no name or description for any of the games.  I guess they figured their target audience couldn't read anyways?

The format of each game is simple.  Four random Sesame Street characters (the only ones I've seen so far are Ernie, Bert, The Count, Grover, and Elmo) go inside the famous Sesame Street apartment building, and take their places at four different windows.  Big Bird comes out from hiding and issues you a question, and Little Bird is used as a cursor.  You select the appropriate window, and once you've answered four questions correctly, one of the characters comes out of the building and does a little animation to celebrate (Elmo blows a bubble, The Count juggles numbered balls, etc).

The six games comes in three different flavors: two of them are about identifying the correct Sesame Street character, two are about finding the correct letter, and two are about spelling three-letter words. In the first game, the four characters are clearly visible, and you just pick the one Big Bird asks for.  In the second, you see the characters for several seconds, and then the windows close and you have to remember where each one was.  The third and fourth are repeats of the first two except each character has a letter, and Big Bird asks for letters instead of names.  On the fifth game, you have to spell a word using three of the four letters available, and in the sixth you have to spell as many words as you can before a cartoon sun reaches the bottom of the screen.

On the whole, as an educational game, this one works all right.  The overly simple controls and Big Bird verbally speaking instructions makes this game playable even for very small children.  There's not much to be learned from the "find the characters" modes, since you don't even have to guess at their location (as you would in a game like Memory); the real meat of the game seems to be learning your letters and spelling.  It's not the best letter and spelling game I've ever played, but it is the best one I've found so far on the NES.

Graphics & Animation: 3 (Good)
Bird Bird and his friends are all nicely rendered here.  The game doesn't have too many sprites, so the developers wisely put that extra space to use with oversized sprites for all the characters.  The Big Bird that skates onto the title screen is particularly impressive for the NES.

Music & Sounds: 3 (Good)
Big Bird talks!  The digitized speech isn't perfect; I had trouble telling if he was asking me for a "b" r a "v".  Still, for the first talking NES game, it's hard to be too critical; even by 1994 (the end of the NES's life cycle), this was still impressive.

Controls & Level Design: 2 (Average)
If you read my review for Sesame Street: A-B-C, you know how frustrated I was that the game won't accept valid words if it's not the word the game is looking for.  I've played several rounds of Big Bird's Hide & Speak and haven't come across this problem.  The controls here are almost frustratingly simplistic, but that's appropriate for the target audience, and you can quickly jump back to the main menu at any time.

Story & Presentation: 2 (Average)
It's odd how text-free the menu screens are.  Don't be fooled by the screen shots; when you play the game, it's really easy to miss the "title screen" among the other screens of text that flash by.  I am however impressed by their dedication to recreating not only the characters but the sets from Sesame Street; the famous brownstone apartment building is instantly recognizable, as is the made-from-doors fence that surrounds Big Bird's nest.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 1 (Bad)
My only real complain about this game is I would have liked a couple more modes; maybe numbers in addition to letters, or at least a harder version of the find-the-characters game.  The game as it stands is a little on the simplistic side, but it's still heads and shoulders over games like Fisher Price: I Can Remember.

Total: 11 (Average)

Monday, January 18, 2016

Super Mario Bros. 3

Name: Super Mario Bros. 3
Year: 1990
Publisher: Nintendo
Developer: Nintendo
Genre: Platformer
Hours Played: Countless
Beaten: Yes, countless times
In a lot of ways, Super Mario Bros. 3 was Nintendo's swan song for the Nintendo Entertainment System.  It wasn't the last game they produced for the NES, not by a long shot, but after five years (longer in Japan) of producing games for the eight-bit system, this would be their last concentrated effort before focusing their best and brightest on the NES's successor (the Super Nintendo, released one year later).

Looking back now, it's hard to imagine the hype for this game (everything from commercials to feature-length films), but people were excited, and the game did not disappoint.  Even today, it's generally considered to be the all-time best Mario game, and sometimes even the best game ever made.  Although that last one may be going a little far, there's no doubt that it's an enduring classic that's aged well even today.  But sinse we here at All Game Revue frown at taking a game's legacy in account, let's take a look at the game itself and see if it holds up well against it's NES brethren.

The original Super Mario Bros. was an exceptional platformer that set the standard for what people expected on the NES.  The second game took the series in a different directions and left a lot of fans scratching their heads.  Super Mario Bros. 3 returned to the formula of the original game and expanded upon it in every way possible.  There were more power-ups.  You could now play levels in different orders.  You could even collect power-ups and save them for later use.  Every single enemy from the original game not only returned, but received either upgrades or new variants, and their were a host of new and memorable enemies as well.

The only downside?  I wouldn't call the game "rushed", considering how many levels it has (around ninety!), but there's definetly concepts that don't feel fully utilized.  Fan-favorite items like the Tanooki Suit, Hammer Bros. Suit, and Goomba's Shoe appear in only one or two places in the game; I've often wished they'd placed the suit-wearing gimmick at the forefront of the game (like Capcom's Little Nemo: Dream Master), as it's such an interesting and fun idea.  Still, even this has become one of the game's charms; while most NES games were conservative with their limited resources and wouldn't introduce a power or enemy unless they could use (and reuse) it to it's fullest, Mario 3 wasn't afraid to throw tons of things against the wall to see what sticks.  That's what made it an enduring classic, then and now: you never know what to expect next.  I've been playing this game for over 25 years, and it can still surprise me; that's pretty darn cool.

Graphics & Animation: 4 (Excellent)
The graphics here are terrific!  Nintendo took the already-iconic character designs of the first game and gave them bold black outlines to really make them pop from their surroundings.  The enemies have tons of personality, and the transformations of the kings still makes me smile today.  Nintendo re-released this game with a graphical update (both in Super Mario All-Stars and Super Mario Advanced 4), and a lot of people (including myself) still prefer the original.

Music & Sounds: 4 (Excellent)
Nintendo actually included a special sound chip in the cartridge to create all the drum effects in the game.  The result is music that doesn't sound like anything else on the NES, and really showcases what the machine is capable of.

Controls & Level Design: 4 (Excellent)
The controls here are spot-on.  The level design is excellent, knowing when to show off new features (like flying with the raccoon power-up) and when to give you a straight-forward challenge.  The game is constantly throwing something new at you, meaning you never get bored, and you're always waiting to see what's coming next...

Story & Presentation: 3 (Good)
The presentation here is very creative, with the game being presented as a stage show (complete with curtains and props you can walk behind).  The story is a little lackluster; although it progresses through static cutscenes (letters from the Princess between worlds), it doesn't really go anywhere until (SPOILERS! I guess?) she's kidnapped at the begging of World 8, begging the question of what exactly your quest was before.  Also, the bosses are pretty underwhelming; compared to the giant enemies of the Mega Man series, the bosses here aren't even as intimidating at the normal enemies in World 4.  Still, the gimmick of the kings being turned into animals is pretty entertaining, and it keeps you playing the game to see what animal will be sitting on the throne next.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 4 (Excellent)
This is (in my opinion) the game's greatest strength; Super Mario Bros. 3 is easily one of the most replayable games on the NES.  The full game is massive, but the warp flutes allow you to explore at your leisure; you can skip straight to the end, jump around to your favorite worlds, or try to beat the whole game front to back.  To this day, I still haven't beaten level in the game; World 7 in particular continues to frustrate me, and yet that's never deterred me from loving the game or coming back for more!

Total: 19 (Excellent)

Friday, January 15, 2016

Pinball

Name: Pinball
Year: 1985
Publisher: Nintendo
Developer: Nintendo
Genre:Pinball
Hours Played: One
Beaten: N/A
Before the advent of arcade games, pinball machines reigned supreme as the nation's number one non-gambling quarter muncher.  The premise of pinball machines is simple: a steel ball richoettes around a slightly elevated playing field, and you control paddles to catch, aim, and prevent the ball from falling out of bounds.  When video games hit the home market, adapting virtual pinball machines that people could play at home was a natural fit, and thus, one of the initial sixteen games released for the NES was Nintendo's own Pinball.

Of the six pinball games released for the NES, the boringly named Pinball is easily the worst.  The graphics are bland, the music is non-existent, and there's only one table, making this a game you'll grow tired of very quickly.  There's two screens (an upper level and a lower level) you can bounce in-between, and a sparse number of ramps and bumpers.  There's no real theme to the table, either; there's eggs that hatch into chicks, dancing penguins and seals, and playing cards.  It's a shame since theming is such a big part of real-life pinball machines; the real life Mario pinball game is much more interesting than anything shown here.

The only real interesting thing is a mini-game you access by hitting one of the bonus spots; it takes you to a Breakout-style mini game where Mario bounces the pinball around to rescue Pauline.  It says something about how boring the rest of the game is that the picture on the box is actually from the mini-game.  Unfortunately, the whimsy of the bonus game doesn't seem to jive with the relatively straight-forward presentation of the regular game.

While Pinball is certainly the worst pinball game for the NES, you could argue a lot of the problems (simplistic presentation, only one table) come from being one of the first games released for the system.  What I can't explain, however, is the mishmash of realism (the main tables) and surrealism (Mario-themed Breakout mini game).  There's two camps on how to approach pinball video games: create a realistic simulation (like Pin*Bot), or include video game elements such as enemies and bosses (like Pinball Quest).  Both ways are valid options, and both have their die-hard fans.  The problem comes when you try to have it both ways; you end up pleasing no one.

Graphics & Animation: 1 (Bad)
I wouldn't call the graphics awful; I mean, you can tell what everything is suppose to be.  However, I would call them about as boring and uninspired as humanly possible.

Music & Sounds: 0 (Awful)
If your not going to have any music (besides the generic black box title theme) in your pinball game, that should be because you don't want to distract from your realistic pinball table sounds.  Unfortunately, those aren't so good either.

Controls & Level Design: 1 (Bad)
The controls here are fairly average for a pinball game; with a little luck and a lot of skill, you can get the ball where you want it.  However, I'm docking a point for not having tilt, a feature in pinball video games that mimics the real life technique of shaking the machine a little bit to get the ball over a ledge or slope.

Story & Presentation: 0 (Awful)
As I stated before, every real-life pinball machine has a theme, and every obstacle and bonus mechanism in the game will be centered around that theme.  The game already has Mario in it, so why not feature him, his enemies, and warp pipes on the game's main mode?  Instead, I guess it's a pinball game about... birds and playing cards?

Length & Replayabilitiy: 0 (Awful)
You'll see everything this game has to offer you inside of five minutes.

Total: 2 (Awful)

Wednesday, January 13, 2016

Balloon Fight

Name: Balloon Fight
Year: 1985
Publisher: Nintendo
Developer: Nintendo
Genre: Arcade
Hours Played: Countless
Beaten: N/A
In my review for Excite Bike, I suggest that of the original sixteen games released for the NES (also known as the "black box series"), only Super Mario Bros. and Excite Bike enjoyed popularity in America past their initial run.  You might be wondering, are their any other black box games that still hold up?  The answer is a resounding yes.

Balloon Fight is a game developed by Nintendo and originally released to arcades in 1984.  Conceived as a "clone" (gamer slang for "rip-off") of arcade classic Joust, Balloon Fight expanded upon the formula in enough ways to become a memorable game in it's own right.  In the main game, you play a balloonist who flies around platforms, popping your enemies' balloons while trying to avoid getting your own balloons popped.  When an enemy's balloon is popped, they plummet to the ground, and if they land on a floating platform, you have a few seconds to finish them off before they inflate a new balloon and return as a more powerful opponent (in the tradition of games like Mario Bros. and Bubble Bobble).  Falling into the water underneath the platforms is instant death, and if you hover too near, a hungry fish waits to attack friend and foe alike.  Other obstacles, such as clouds that shoot lighting and the bumpers from Smash Bros, serve to further compound matters.

Balloon Fight improves upon the basic Joust formula in several ways.  First of all, the controls are stronger, and you'll never die from a cheap shot you couldn't react to.  The slippery momentum is gone here, making the controls more about judging how fast you should flap your arms (to gain lift) at any certain time.  There's more level variety here, too; the first three levels serve as a practice, similar to Joust, and then levels four through twelve cycle indefinitely.  Each level has it's own layout and placement of obstacles to keep you on your toes.

The biggest addition here, and something I wish a lot more NES arcade ports had done, is the addition of a second, simple but awesome mini-game called Balloon Trip.  Basically, it's Flappy Bird, almost twenty years before Flappy Bird existed.  You navigate your balloonist through a never-ending randomly generated maze of electric sparks to get the highest score possible.  It's challenging yet oddly relaxing at the same time, and easily qualifies as it's own game, making the fifty dollar price tag a lot easier to swallow.

Balloon Fight is at it's heart a Joust clone, but it expands upon the formula in so many ways, and came out so much earlier then Joust's NES port, that you could be forgiven for assuming Joust ripped off of Balloon Fight.  The greater variety of levels, plus the addition of the excellent Balloon Trip mini-game, makes this "tribute" a clear superior to it's predecessor.

Graphics & Animation: 2 (Average)
The graphics are simple but charming; I especially like the way the enemy bird-men use a bicycle pump to re-inflate their balloons.  Little touches like this, and the animation on the collectible balloons, show how much a little extra attention can elevate a game.

Music & Sounds: 1 (Bad)
The Balloon Fight theme is actually pretty catchy; too bad what you'll mostly hear during gameplay is the annoying bicycle-squeak sound effect of enemy's flapping their wings.  The other sound effects are pretty satisfying, especially popping balloons, and the theme does play on loop during the Balloon Trip game.

Controls & Level Design: 4 (Excellent)
The controls here are great, giving you the perfect blend of challenge and precision.  The level design is a little on the simple side, with little variety, but  it lends itself well to the constant chaos happening on screen at any given time, and the randomly generated nature of Balloon Trip (a rarity on the NES!) means you can play endlessly without getting bored.

Story & Presentation: 2 (Average)
In true arcade fashion, their's basically no story whatsoever (the manual doesn't even give the poor balloonist a name).  The presentation is simple but appealing, with little touches like an animated balloon serving as your menu cursor elevating things a little.  I especially like the fact  that the whole of the game takes place at night, with stars always twinkling in the background; it provides a nice change of pace from the usual "blue skies and clouds" background of so many platforms on the NES.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 3 (Good)
Easily one of the best of the one-screen platform games on the NES.  You can get into that arcade groove, but things are hectic enough that you can never truly relax, and the randomly generated mazes of Balloon Trip ensure you can play forever without getting bored.

Total: 12 (Average)

Monday, January 11, 2016

Joust

Name: Joust
Year: 1988
Publisher: HAL America Inc.
Developer: Williams Electronics Inc.
Genre: Arcade
Hours Played: One Hour
Beaten: N/A
Williams Electronics, a company known primarily for making pinball machines, dipped it's toe into the arcade game market in the early eighties; perhaps it's no surprise that one of their first hits, Joust, involves bouncing around obstacles at high velocity.

In Joust, you play a knight riding atop an ostrich (or in two-player mode, a stork) battling even knights riding vultures above a volcano.  In true arcade fashion, all the action takes place on one screen, and you get around by rapidly tapping the jump button to flap your wings.  The mechanic is similar to the swimming controls in some video games, but there's also a momentum element; if your ostrich touches the ground, he'll brake into a run, and you end up running into platforms and careening all over the place.  The goal is to take out the enemy knights, which is done by touching them when you're higher then you are; if you collide dead on, you'll bounce off each other, and if they're higher then you, you'll lose a life.  The frantic pace of the game is part of the appeal; ideally it should be easy to always hover at the top of the screen so you're unbeatable, but the slippery nature of the controls and constant clutter of the screen ensure that you're always bumping around  and trying to reposition yourself.

The first two levels serve as basic training; there's safety platforms over the lava to make thing a little easier.  After level two, the platforms disappear, and fiery hands will appear to yank you into the lava if you get too close.  Defeated knights drop eggs, and if you don't destroy them in time, they hatch into more powerful knights.  As the levels progress, platforms disappear; while this is meant to make the game harder, it actually gives you less obstacles to bump into, making things a little easier.

Joust game demands you pay constant attention to your surroundings, and it's pretty challenging and fun, if not a bit repetitive.  It's a solid arcade game, but as a complete package it's pretty lacking.  If you're a fan of Joust, I highly recommend Nintendo's own Balloon Fight, which improves upon the formula in several ways, and even adds a second game mode that's reminiscent of Flappy Bird.

Graphics & Animation: 2 (Average)
There's not a lot going on, but what's here is pretty good.  The characters boast an impressive amount of colors per sprite (six, as opposed to three as in most NES games) and the volcano floor is well detailed.

Music & Sounds: 1 (Bad)
It's not that the music is terrible; their just isn't any music, aside from a little tune on the start screen.  No music when you die, no music at game over.  The sound effects when you flap your wings are satisfying, but not anything you consciously notice when you play.

Controls & Level Design: 2 (Average)
Joust is the sort of game where the tricky controls are intended to be part of the challenge, and Joust straddles this line perfectly.  Despite careening all over the place, it still always feels like your fault when you die... well, at least in the case of the controls themselves.  There's no invulnerability when you respawn, so if you appear in the wrong place you can lose a life before you have a chance to do anything.  Also, the pterodactyl is extremely random and can spawn right where you're hanging out, again costing you a life before you have a chance to react.

Story & Presentation: 2 (Average)
There's some nice presentation here: the title screen gives an appropriately medieval feel, and the "welcome to Joust" screen adds a little epicness to the proceedings. When the lava pit becomes accessible, the platforms above it actually catch fire and burn, which is a very nice touch.  Like the rest of the game, it's well executed; there's just not much of it.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 1 (Awful)
This is definitely one of those "play it over and over again for a high score" kind of games...  unless you're a humongous fan of Joust, this just doesn't justify a fifty dollar price tag.

Total: 8 (Average)