Showing posts with label Educational. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Educational. Show all posts

Friday, January 22, 2016

Sesame Street: Countdown

Name: Sesame Street: Countdown
Year: 1992
Publisher: Hi-Tech Expressions
Developer: Riedel Software Productions
Genre: Educational
Hours Played: 2
Beaten: Yes
Sesame Street: Countdown was the last Sesame Street game released for the Nintendo Entertainment System.  Like the previous game (and unlike the first two), the game was developed specifically for the NES, and includes digitized speech.

The first thing you'll notice about Sesame Street: Countdown is that there's two modes, Hop and Run.  My feelings about the game vary greatly depending on which mode you pick.  If you pick Run, the game becomes an adequate (if enemy-less) platformer, not unlike Mickey's Safari in Letterland. Each level starts with a wheel of chance, which determines the number you'll be searching for in that level.  You then walk around as the Count, occasionally jumping or climbing on obstacles, looking for the number, groupings of objects that equal the number (e.g. a cluster of four ghosts if your number is 4), and lightning bolts.  Grabbing these things will gain you a point, and grabbing a wrong number or grouping will cost you a life point.  You begin the game with nine life points and only a three point minimum to finish the level, but with each subsequent level you need one more point and have one less hit point.  The game's hit detection is slightly off, but I actually think this was on purpose; you can brush a wrong number without being punished for it.

Where the game falls apart is when you pick Hop.  The idea here is to make the game playable, even for very small children.  It's the same game, with the same levels and the same game of chance at the beginning, but all of the platforming is removed.  Instead, the numbers and item groups are spaced out an even distance from one another, and instead of moving with the D-pad, you use either A or B to hop.  A hops you to the next number or grouping, while B makes you hop straight up, collecting it (or taking a hit).  All of the Sesame Street NES games share this problem to a certain extent, but Countdown by far has it the worst: by trying to simplify the controls, they actually make them more confusing.  While using a D pad feels very intuitive, trying to figure out which button hops you in the right direction does not.  I have trouble picturing a four year old, or an elderly parental figure trying to play with their child, being able to figure this out, and anybody in-between those two ages should be playing with the normal controls anyways.

In the end, I'm torn.  The educational value is certainly there; The Count teaches you how to count at the end of each level, and collecting groupings of objects (instead of just the number) will help your kids learn how to apply counting instead of just memorizing it.  The game was clearly built around Run mode, and as a "baby's first platformer", it works.  Hop mode, however, is a mess, and it's also the default mode (you have to move the cursor to pick "Run"), meaning it's the first, and probably only, mode most people will play.

Graphics & Animation: 2 (Average)
The graphics here are fine.  The Count is instantly recognizable, which of course is the most important thing, The first level takes place on Sesame Street, and the remaining six levels take place in locales ranging from prehistoric times to the moon, and finishing with the Count's castle.  Everything is recognizable, but not much stands out.

Music & Sounds: 4 (Excellent)
The Count talks!  The digitized voice here is very good, and the Count's counting sounds very natural, which is harder to pull off with digitized speech then you'd think (I'm looking at you, Mickey).  The music is fine as well, although I wish they'd included the classic theme song.

Controls & Level Design: 1 (Bad)
Honestly, I wish I could score the two modes as separate games.  Run mode controls pretty well, and being able to brush against an object without activating it, while annoying in most games, is actually a pretty nice touch here, as it means kids can accidentally bump into a wrong answer without getting penalized.  Hop mode, on the other hand, is inexcusably bad.

Story & Presentation: 2 (Average)
Like everything else with this game, I'm really torn on the presentation.  On the one hand, if you collect a lightning bolt, and you're already maxed out, the lightning bolt will fly up towards your status bar, ricochet off the lightning bolt tally box, and then fly exasperatedly away.  That's a really creative touch!  On the other hand, after beating a bonus challenge in the sky, the Count unceremoniously levitates  down the screen to the ground, making the game feel amateurish.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 1 (Bad)
Once again, I'm torn.  The random nature of which number you're looking for does give the game a little replayability, but by the time you finish the game's seven levels, you'll feel like you've seen everything the game has to offer.  If they had just left out Hop mode...

Total: 10 (Average)

Monday, January 4, 2016

Fisher-Price: Firehouse Rescue

Name: Fisher-Price: Firehouse Rescue
Year: 1992
Publisher: GameTek
Developer: GameTek
Genre: Educational
Hours Played: Half an Hour
Beaten: Yes
Fisher-Price: Firehouse Rescue is one of three Fisher-Price DOS games to be ported to the NES.  The gameplay is simple; first, you must navigate a maze from the firehouse to an emergency; secondly, you must rescue people (or a cat) from a "burning" building (or tree).  How many people (one or two) and the complexity of the maze varies depending on the chosen difficulty level.

The mazes in this game are actually pretty nice.  They're viewed from overhead and resemble the mazes found in any coloring or activity book.  They have a time limit, and the more complicated mazes on the hardest difficulty could actually stump a younger child.  Unfortunately the rescue part of the game isn't nearly as good.  You simply drive your fire engine so that the ladder is underneath the rescue-ee, then hit the button.  There's really no challenge or possibility of failure, and their's no attempt whatsoever to make it look like the buildings are on fire.

Of the three Fisher-Price games for the Nintendo Entertainment System, Firehouse Rescue is easily the best.  While that's not saying very much, I can at least honestly say that I might actually recommend this game, presuming it's free, to a very small child as their first NES game.

Graphics & Animation: 1 (Bad)
The mazes look alright, but GameTek's attempt to render Fisher-Price Little People figures and vechicles is pretty terrible.

Music & Sounds: 0 (Awful)
Like the other NES Fisher Price games, they didn't bother to update the public domain music of the DOS original.  Hope you like Entry of the Gladiators!

Controls & Level Design: 2 (Average)
The maze portion of the game is actually kind of fun!  The fire truck controls well, the mazes are well designed (even the ones on the easiest difficulty level are still more challenging then the mazes found on the back of some restaurant children's menus), and the game randomly picks one of several mazes each time you play.  Honestly, they should have dropped the whole "rescue people" aspect and made a kid's maze game, and they might of had something.

Story & Presentation: 0 (Awful)
Take a look at that title screen screenshot!  Doesn't that blank forest-green background totally get you pumped to go save some lives?  A game about firefighters should have been incredibly easy to theme (firehouse brick background for the title screen, a fire bell for the menu screen cursor, etc), but they made absolutely no attempt whatsoever.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 1 (Bad)
There's several difficulty levels, and the game rotates mazes so that you can't just memorize them.  Had this been the whole game, it might be worth playing for maze enthusiasts.  However, the monotony of the no-challenge people rescuing gets old really quick.

Total: 4 (Bad)

Monday, December 21, 2015

Fisher-Price: Perfect Fit

Name: Fisher Price: Perfect Fit
Year: 1990
Publisher: GameTek
Developer: Beam Software
Genre: Educational
Hours Played: Half an Hour
Beaten: Yes
Like all three NES Fisher-Price games, Perfect Fit began life as a DOS game.  The computer operating system that preceded Windows, DOS was primarily text-based, and while some (but not all) DOS games did have graphics, they tended to be crudely drawn, have a limited color palette, and more often then not they featured either no music, or a public domain soundtrack (i.e. classical music, children's songs, etc).  As was only natural, when the Nintendo Entertainment System gained popularity in the US, a lot of computer companies ported their previously DOS-only games to the NES.  Since the NES was technically superior, these conversions tended to be upgrades: better graphics, real music, etc.  Not so with Fisher Price: Perfect Fit.

The idea here is that the game gives you one picture at a time, and you have to match that picture to it's outline on a grid.  On easy, you literally just move the picture over it's outline and hit the button.  On the hardest setting, the picture might be backwards or upside down, and there's buttons that let you flip the picture to straighten it out.  That last bit would actually be pretty clever, except with some of the pictures it's a little too subtle; for instance, the only way to tell the Fisher-Price cassette tape is backwards is to look for the FP on the label.  Speaking of which, the Fisher-Price product placement makes a return here, but there's also letters and numbers to place, giving the game a modicum of educational value.

All in all, Perfect Fit is a pretty poor excuse for a game.  Some may question whether it's even worse then Fisher Price: I Can Remember; after all, Memory is a real game that people pay money for, and at least it has some arguable educational value.  To those remarks, I say this: number one, Perfect Fit isn't included as a free mini-game on hundreds of other video games, and number two: while I didn't enjoy playing Perfect Fit, I also didn't fall asleep.  That's faint praise, though; this is still easily one of the worst games on the NES.

Graphics & Animation: 0 (Awful)
Although several of my sources tell me this was originally a DOS game, MobyGames has it listed as NES only.  If that's true, they sure went through a lot of trouble to make this look like shoddy 80's PC shareware.

Music & Sounds: 0 (Awful)
PCs in the eighties only had one sound channel.  The NES had five.  Guess how many this game uses?  Feel like hearing public domain children's song blared at top speed one note at a time?  Then you're in luck!

Controls & Level Design: 1 (Bad)
The whole game is about lining up pictures over their shadows.  Well, you'd better make sure you've lined it up exactly, because if you're off by even a little bit, the game tells you you're wrong.  When you're aiming your game at very small children, this is inexcusable.

Story & Presentation: 0 (Awful)
The best thing I can say about this game is that they got rid of the annoying angry buzzer from I Can Remember.  Sure, navigating the menus is still unintuitive, but at least the game no longer punishes you for not being able to figure it out.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 1 (Bad)
Perfect Fit has a two player mode, a versus the computer mode, a solo mode, and three levels of difficulty.  If this was a five dollar shareware game for PC on the eighties (which I suspect it was), I'd actually be pretty impressed by it.  But as a fifty dollar game for the NES, this is just a mess.

Total: 2 (Awful)

Fisher-Price: I Can Remember

Name: Fisher-Price: I Can Remember
Year: 1990
Publisher: GameTek
Developer: Beam Software
Genre: Educational
Hours Played: Don't know, fell asleep
Beaten: Yes, at least once
When I started this blog, I picked for my first post Color a Dinosaur, because I was confident it would be the worst game I ever reviewed for the NES.  Well folks, I'm only about thirty games in, and I may have found one that's worse.  I've played a lot of bad video games, but I've never in my life found myself nodding off during a game before.

At it's core, I Can Remember is just a game of Memory.  There's a set number of cards on the table, and you take turns flipping over cards two at a time; if the two cards you pick match, they disappear and part of a picture appears below.  Match all the cards, and the entire hidden picture is revealed. Not particularly inspired, but unlike, say, dinosaur coloring, it's at least an actual game you can actually play.  So what exactly is the problem here?

Well first of all,  everything in this game takes forever.  You pick a card, it slowly flips over.  You pick a second card, it slowly flips over.  They don't match?  They slowly flip back.  They do match?  They slowly disappear, and the hidden picture slowly reveals itself.  I literally found myself fighting to stay awake at one point.  Secondly is the pictures themselves: they're all Fisher-Price toys!  You can flip over cards with toy telephones, or ring stacks, and when you reveal the hidden picture, it might be a rocking horse!  All available at your local toy store!  I see people mock games like M.C. Kids for their in-game product placement, but this is about the worst I've seen that wasn't a free game included in a box of cereal; even the Burger King would be embarrassed by this.

But the biggest problem here is just how little effort seems to have went into this.  Seriously, this is the first NES game I've ever played where I've seriously wondered if it was made by one guy.  For instance, if you play on the highest difficulty level, the game deals out twenty cards, and they fill the screen.  So when you pick the easiest setting and it deals only 12 cards, how do you think the developers handle it?  Scale the cards up to fill the screen?  Have blank spaces at the top and bottom?  Nope!  The game still shows twenty cards, but if you try to pick from the top four or bottom four, the game buzzes angrily at you to let you know that you're in the wrong.  Yeah, that's definitely pretty educational!

On a personal note, I dabbled in amateur game design myself for a little while.  I was honestly pretty terrible at it, but even I managed to make a playable Memory game.  Do you know why?  Because Memory is one of the easiest games to program.  Seriously, when you're teaching people how to program games, it's usually the second game you teach, right after "guess a number".  There's a reason why it's such a common mini-game in other games you buy.  For fifty bucks in the nineties, you could buy Super Mario Bros. 3, with a card matching mini-game that's infinity better then this one, AND the entire game of Super Mario Bros. 3 to go with it!  Or, you could pay fifty bucks for an advertisement from Fisher Price.

Graphics & Animation: 0 (Awful)
This game looks terrible.  I had no idea it was possible to replicate CGA graphics on the NES, and I still have no idea why you would want to, but they sure pulled it off!

Music & Sounds: 0 (Awful)
All the music here public domain.  Yeah, unlike Color a Dinosaur, which had you coloring your dinosaurs mostly in silence, there's plenty of music here; you're constantly assaulted with super-loud renditions of Old MacDonald and Twinkle Twinkle Little Star.  And don't even get me started on the awful buzzing sound when you're wrong, or if you just do something the game doesn't like.

Controls & Level Design: 0 (Awful)
Before you're allowed to play, the game forces you to pick a name, even if you're playing by yourself.  You're given a grid of letters, and you pick letters to spell your name.  Now, in most games, hitting left when your cursor is on the left-most side would cause it to jump over to the right-hand side, and making a name of the maximum length would cause the cursor to jump automatically to "done".  Not only does this game not include these small but handy features, but it actually buzzes angrily at you when you try to do them!  There's even a couple of blank spaces the developers left there out of sloppiness, and you get buzzed for trying to pick them, too.  This is the kind of design and controls we're talking about; the game hasn't even started yet, and I'm ready to hurt somebody.

Story & Presentation: 0 (Awful)
This was originally a DOS game, and it's almost impressive how little work they clearly did to move it over to the NES.  It's not that DOS games are terrible by nature, it's just that they're technically inferior to what the NES can offer.  This should have been an upgrade, not a lateral move.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 0 (Awful)
This is the only category I considered giving the same a (single) point in.  Yes, it does have one and two players, play against the computer, and play against yourself, and there are three levels of difficulty, so clearly they put a little effort in, right?  That's until you actually try the different modes and see how little effort was put into each one of them.

Total: 0 (Lowest Possible Score)

Tuesday, December 15, 2015

Sesame Street: 1-2-3

Name: Sesame Street: 1-2-3
Year: 1989
Publisher: Hi-Tech Expressions
Developer: Beam Software
Genre: Educational
Hours Played: 2
Beaten: N/A
In 1989, Hi-Tech Expressions released two collections of old DOS Sesame Street educational games packaged as two-packs for the NES.  One was Sesame Street A-B-C, which taught letters, and the other one is Sesame Street 1-2-3, which teaches math, shapes, and colors.  In this review we'll be looking at the latter.

The first game, Ernie's Magic Shapes, is about shape and color matching.  A shape appears over Ernie's head, and a second one appears over his magic hat.  Hitting the direction pad cycle through different options (it doesn't matter what direction you push, but given the game is aimed at three year olds, that's understandable), and when you find a shape of matching size and color, you hit A or B.  If you get it right, a bunny pops out from the hat and celebrates; if you get it wrong, he shakes his head at you.  There's quite a few game modes, from a tutorial, to matching only colors, only shapes, both, or picking from multiple shapes to create a picture.

The second game, Astro-Grover, is geared towards counting and math.  The idea is there's little aliens, called Zips, and you have to match the number of Zips shown on the screen.  There's multiple game modes, and they all play differently; in one you count the Zips then pick the right number, in another you're given a number and must pick the group of Zips that equals the right amount.  In the more difficult modes, you add and subtract; unlike Mickey's Adventure in Numberland, which presents you with a math problem and then acts like it taught you something, in Astro-Grover the problems are always illustrated with Zips; even if you can't work the problem yourself, you can still count the Zips on screen and get the right answer.  This is a pretty effective way to teach the basic concepts of mathematics.

I gave Sesame Street A-B-C a pretty hard time in it's review, suggesting that Letter-Go-Round did a poor job of teaching reading, and that Ernie's Big Splash didn't teach much of anything.  This game is a much better effort, and definitely one of the more educational games for the NES.  If this were the early Nineties and I was buying a game for my four-year-old, this is probably the game I'd go with.

Graphics & Animation: 3 (Good)
Like Sesame Street A-B-C, they definitely put more effort into the graphics then they really had to.  Ernie's Magic Shapes takes place at a magic show, complete with stage and curtains.  There's two screens for Astro-Grover, one involving a night sky over a neighborhood with an onlooking moon.  Astro-Grover in particular seems to have a lot of effort put into the animation; unfortunately they slow the game down, as you're not allowed to keep playing until things are done moving around.

Music & Sounds: 1 (Bad)
The songs here are pleasant enough, if forgettable.  There's no jingle or sound effect to tell you when you're wrong, though, and I miss the Sesame Street theme that was so lovingly recreated in Sesame Street A-B-C.

Controls & Level Design: 2 (Average)
The controls are simple enough for little kids.  It's funny how in most places, which button you hit on the D-pad doesn't matter, but in a couple of the Astro-Grover games, it doesn't.  I won't fault that though, as I feel like the games that utilize it are aimed at slightly older kids then the rest.  While Ernie's Magic Shapes feels like one game with several different modes, the modes in Astro-Grover are varied enough to legitimately feel like several different games, which is nice.

Story & Presentation: 2 (Average)
As with the graphics, the presentation here has more effort put into it then was strictly necessary.  Little touches like the rabbit, moon, or Grover shaking their head when you get things wrong go a long way towards selling the game.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 3 (Good)
Sesame Street 1-2-3 has an impressive amount of modes for different skill levels.  Between shapes, colors, counting, and simple mathematics, there's a lot to learn here, and unlike most "educational" games for the NES, I feel like someone actually had some kids play and test these games to make sure they were effective.  Astro-Grover may be no Math Blaster, but he's the best the NES has to offer.

Total: 11 (Average)

Thursday, December 3, 2015

Sesame Street: A-B-C

Name: Sesame Street: A-B-C
Year: 1989
Publisher: Hi-Tech Expressions
Developer: Zippo Games
Genre: Educational
Hours Played: Countless
Beaten: N/A
In 1989, Hi-Tech took a quarto of previously released Sesame Street computer games and ported them as two-packs for the NES; Sesame Street 1-2-3, which includes Astro Grover (counting game) and Ernie's Magic Shapes (shapes & color game), and Sesame Street A-B-C, which includes Letter-Go-Round (ABC's) and Ernie's Big Splash (um... spatial reasoning?).  They later released all four games on a single cartridge, but as per our rule on multi-carts, we won't be covering that here.

Now, I'm not afraid to give an educational game a good score, but Sesame Street A-B-C sadly just isn't all that educational.  Letter-Go-Round is meant to teach letters, but it does this by either matching letters (matching captial A to captial A teaches matching skills, sure, but not letter recognition) or by having you spell words.  The problem with the world spelling portion of the game is, you're meant to fill in the blanks by picking from the letters they give you... Only they often give you more then one letter that fits (for example, _AR, with the choices C, F, T, and X).  Not only is their no indication of what letter you're suppose to pick, but spelling a perfectly valid (but incorrect) word gives you the same response as picking a ludicrously wrong choice (like the X).

The other game, Ernie's Big Splash, scores slightly better in that you can at least have fun with it.  The basic premises is the same as Pipe Dreams or Loopz - you have to put down tiles to guide Rubber Duckie to Ernie's bathtub.  There's no time limit or limit on which tiles you can use, so it's no stress, and cute little animations play as Rubber Duckie makes his trek.  It's charming, but I'm not exactly sure what children are suppose to be learning from it... basic reasoning skills, I suppose.

I feel bad being so hard on this game... I loved Sesame Street growing up, and my kids love it now.  But for an educational game to get a good score, it needs to be good at either the educational part, or the game part; preferably both.  This game does neither.


Graphics & Animation: 3 (Good)
The graphics are the high point here... There's plenty of Sesame Street characters packed in (excluding Elmo, who wasn't popular yet), and they're all big and colorful and easily recognizable. The carnival scene in Letter-Go-Round is surprisingly atmospheric.  During Ernie's Big Splash, each tile has a different animation as Rubber Duckie makes his way to the bathtub, and it encourages you to try each tile, just to see what they all do.

Music & Sounds: 2 (Average)
There's four Sesame Street games for the NES, and this is the only one to feature the Sesame Street theme song... complete with a little sing-a-long!  Other then that there's not a lot of music to be had.

Controls & Level Design: 1 (Bad)
The controls are fine, there's just not a lot to do., and the level design is almost non existent.  One game is a still screen with a spinning Ferris wheel, and the other game is a static screen where you place tiles.

Story & Presentation: 2 (Average)
There's definitely some love put into the presentation... the title screen has a cool little sing-a-long, and the moving background changes depending on which game the cursor is pointing to.  However, other things, like having to reset the NES to switch games, held this score back.

Length & Replayabilitiy: 0 (Awful)
I commend Letter-Go-Round for having so many modes, but it's hard to image spending more then a couple minutes with each.  Ernie's Big Splash might have earned a point, except all three of it's difficulty settings are basically the same thing.  For shame.

Total: 8 (Average)

Tuesday, December 1, 2015

Mickey's Adventure in Numberland

Name: Mickey's Adventure in Numberland
Year: 1994
Publisher: Hi-Tech Expressions
Developer: Beam Software
Genre: Educational
Hours Played: Countless
Beaten: Yes, Many Times
Near the end of the NES's life, Hi-Tech Expressions released two Mickey Mouse themed educational games.  The second game, Mickey's Adventure in Numberland, came out one year after it's predecessor (Mickey's Safari in Letterland), and it shows.  The two games play very similarly, but Numberland builds upon the the first game in many ways.

The game begins with a map with four areas: City, Museum, Observatory, and Factory.  Each area has two levels (although you're returned to the map screen each time you clear one, meaning you need to visit each area twice).  Clear all four, and you open up the final area, Pete's Hideout.  Gone is the world-spanning safari theme of the last game; here, the levels have a very urban feel, and Mickey is dressed in sportswear.  He even has a basketball he fiddles with during his idle animations.

Your objective in each level is to collect a specific number.  Incorrect numbers are sprinkled throughout the level, and Mickey shakes his head disapprovingly if you try to grab the wrong one.  There's bubblegum to collect that you can shoot at the enemies, and you actually have a life meter this time around, making the stakes a little higher (for a game aimed at very young children).  The coolest thing in the levels are the blackboards; they cycle through numbers, and if you land on them when they're displaying the number you're looking for, you get a bonus point.  It's completely optional, but it actually involves a little skill (something rarely seen in edutainment titles).

All in all, Mickey's Adventure in Numberland feels a lot more like a bonafide platformer then it's predecessor.  Sure, it's easy, and a seasoned gamer can beat it in about ten to fifteen minutes, but at least it requires a little skilll, especially when you crank up the difficulty and go for all the bonuses.  The downside to this game is that I'm not sure it really succeeds at being that educational.  There's a single digit addition or subtraction problem at the end of each stage, but the game does nothing to teach you how to work the problem.  Sesame Street: Countdown may be a terrible game, but at least you have to collect the right number of items, instead of just the number.

Graphics & Animation: 3 (Good)
The graphics here are big and colorful.  Your child will instantly recognize Mickey, Donald, and Pete.  Mickey himself has a lot of different animations, including playing with a basketball while waiting for you to hit a button.

Music & Sounds: 4 (Excellent)
Mickey talks!  I said this with the last game, but it still applies here: this was very impressive for the time, and still holds up pretty well today.  Sound bites take up a ton of cartridge space, but they managed to squeeze quite a few clips in.

Controls & Level Design: 2 (Average)
The addition of an attack (and the ability to take damage) add a lot more depth to this outing.  The levels here are longer, but shorter; sadly, gone are the secret passages of the first game's Egypt levels.  You still have to explore the levels pretty thoroughly to find everything, though.

Story & Presentation: 3 (Good)
The story and presentation is the one clear step up in this game.  We now get an opening cut scene showing Pete stealing all the letters, and Mickey and Donald pop up with full screen portraits to give messages to the player.

Length & Replayability: 3 (Average)
This game is shorter then it's predecessor, but I feel like it will entertain you for a little longer.  The levels are longer and more interesting (even though there's only ten of them as opposed to the last game's twenty-six), and there's still three levels of difficulty.  I can also see an older sibling playing this game through at least once (I certainly did with my little brother's copy, back in the day), whereas Letterland would bore any older kid pretty quickly.

Total: 16 (Good)

Friday, November 27, 2015

Mickey's Safari in Letterland

Name: Mickey's Safari in Letterland
Year; 1993
Publisher: Hi-Tech Expressions
Developer: Beam Software
Genre: Educational
Hours Played: One
Beaten: Yes, without cheats
Mickey's Safari in Letterland, and it's sequel Mickey's Adventures in Numberland, are two of the better "edutainment" (educational entertainment) games to come out for the NES.  Both games teach a general concept to kids (in this case, letters) while still playing like a simple low-stress platformer.

Letterland looks suspiciously like a world map.  Mickey picks one of six locations, some of them real places (Yukon, Egypt) and some hilariously non-specific (Forest, Swamp).  You play a short platforming level, and then it's back to the map.  You're meant to play each location several times, traversing a different "stage" of that location each time, but the game doesn't communicate this very well.  Once you've beaten every stage in a given location, it's picture is replaced with a Mickey face, and once every location is completed, the game is over.  No final level here.

The stages themselves are pretty short.  The main goal is getting to the stolen letter at the end, but there's also three letter gems on each board that, when collected, spell a word. Mickey lacks an attack, but the enemies only stun you for a couple seconds anyways; you can't die in this game.  Mickey does have a butterfly net he can swing, but it's only used for picking up letters;  I wish they'd left it out and just let you pick things up by touching them.  Some of the areas are much more difficult then others (slippery slopes in the Yukon, hidden passages in Egypt), but there's nothing on the map screen to suggest this; in fact the cursor defaults to Yukon, which is one of the more difficult levels, instead of starting over an easier location like Forest.

All in all, Mickey's Adventures in Numberland is a better game, but I feel like Mickey's Safari in Letterland is more educational.  My three-year-old sat on my lap while I played this, and he had a blast spelling the words out with Mickey.  Unlike Numberland, which is basically a platformer with a couple math problems thrown in, I can see how a few rounds with this game could actually help him learn to read.  Definitely the best educational game on the NES I've played so far.

Graphics & Animation: 3 (Good)
I'm well aware I'm going to get made fun of for giving Mickey's Safari in Letterland such a high overall score, but darn it if this game doesn't have some of the best graphics and sounds on the NES!  There's cameos by plenty of different Disney characters, and they're all rendered in colorful oversized sprites.  Now, I could argue all day why the sprite size in Ducktales fits the style of gameplay better, but when it comes to which one you're toddler will instantly recognize and identify with (and yes, I tested this), it's this game.

Music & Sounds: 4 (Excellent)
Mickey talks!  This might not sound particularly impressive in today's age of branching dialog trees, but it was pretty impressive back in the days of the NES.  You and I  as adults may not be particularly thrilled to hear Mickey's high-pitched chirpy exclamations, but let's face it; we're not this game's target audience.  My three-year-old, on the other hand, loved every second of it.  And I have to admit, it definitely sounds like Mickey.

Controls & Level Design: 2 (Average)
The controls and level design are definitely skewed towards younger gamers, but it still plays like a platformer, meaning you still have to land jumps.  This is where I'm torn; while the gamer in me wishes it were a little harder, the parent in me thinks this would be way too difficult for someone who's actually still learning the alphabet, as the game assumes.  I doubt this is what the game designers intended, but it's probably best played exactly the way we played it: daddy at controls, toddler in lap.

Story & Presentation: 3 (Good)
Did I mention the graphics?  Everything here is bright and colorful, and even the menu screens are bursting with personality.

Length & Replayability: 3 (Average)
This game has a surprising amount of stages of a game of it's ilk (26, one for each letter of the alphabet!).  It also has three difficulty levels that nicely tailor the game to your little one's skill level.  It may not entertain older gamers for long, but for a younger gamer, you could do a lot worse...

Total: 15 (Good)

Thursday, November 12, 2015

Donkey Kong Jr. Math

Name: Donkey Kong Jr. Math
Year: 1986
Publisher: Nintendo
Developer: Nintendo
Genre: Educational
Hours Played: Half an hour
Beaten: N/A
One of my rules in reviewing games is to make sure I've played each game for a minimum of half an hour.  Since I have to beat each game, it's rarely an issue; there's only two games (so far) that have hurt to play that long.  The first one was Color a Dinosaur; the second is Donkey Kong Jr. Math.

Now, I'm not the kind to hate on a game just for trying to teach kids something - as a former aspiring educational game designer, I loath how "edutainment" has become a dirty word. But this game is painful.  There's three modes: "Calculate A", "Calculate B", and "Exercise".  "Excerise" is graphically based off the fourth screen on Donkey Kong Jr, and feels the most like a math game; the game gives you an equation and you have to solve it.  The weird thing is how you solve it; you climb up chains in increments.  Yeah, that's just as weird as it sounds.

"Calculate A" is the mode you always see in screen shots - it looks like the first screen in Donkey Kong Jr, but full of numbers.  Did you know that Donkey Kong Jr. Math is by default a two-player game?  I sure didn't! And by "default" I mean there isn't a one-player option! (Except for "Excerise" mode) DK JR is on the left side of the screen while a second, pinker DR JR sits on the right side.  Donkey Kong (Sr) holds up a sign with a two or three digit number, and then the two babies race to create the number by collecting combinations of single digit numbers and operators (plus, minus, multiply and divide).  So for example, if he holds up 400, you could multiply 9 by 5 to get 45, then multiply by 9 to get 405, then subtract 5 to get 400!  Fun, right?

The basic problem with this game - besides the awful controls, and the fact that it isn't any fun - is that it's a math game that doesn't teach math.  At least "Exercise" mode lets you practice math exercises.  The "Calculate" modes ("Calculate B" is the same thing, only you have to create negative numbers!) is complicated and unintuitive - even if they had a 10 you could multiply by, it might be playable.  Oh, and the numbers you pick from are random, so there's no guarantee they'll have the one you need!  Learning games tend to be skewed towards younger players, but I'm having trouble picturing the kid who could work all that out with negative numbers and also be willing to play this game.  Bottom line: I'll take Math Blaster any day of the week.

Graphics & Animation: 1 (Bad)
The only redeeming thing about this game is the graphics - it looks just like Donkey Kong Jr! On the other hand, that might be a bad thing - like the game is taunting you that you could be playing a real game.

Music & Sound: 0 (Awful)
The music sounds like you're playing a Donkey Kong Jr. rip-off where they changed just enough notes to not get sued.  Also, you get to listen to a four-second loop while doing math!

Controls & Level Design: 0 (Awful)
How can you break Donkey Kong Jr?? They could have just made a calculator interface and it would have been much easier to play.

Story & Presentation: 0 (Awful)
Maybe the manual has some sort of backstory where Donkey Kong is trying to teach his son math? Could be, but I doubt it could explain DK JR's pink clone.

Length & Replayability: 0 (Awful)
Just be grateful it's so short!

Total: 1 (Awful)